August 03, 2022 Uncategorized

If you were hurt by a driver who had no insurance, or not nearly enough, one of your first questions is probably who’s going to pay your medical bills. In Illinois, the answer is often your own auto policy. State law requires every auto policy to include uninsured motorist (UM) coverage. Many policies also carry underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage, which steps in when the other driver’s limits run out.

That coverage has limits, though, and your insurance company won’t always agree with you about what your claim is worth. Depending on who was driving, whose car it was, and why the crash happened, there may be other places to look as well. An Evanston car accident lawyer can review your policy, identify where compensation can come from, and handle the insurance company for you.

Uninsured vs. Underinsured: What’s the Difference?

The two terms sound alike, but they apply to different situations and trigger different parts of your policy.

Uninsured Drivers

An uninsured driver had no liability insurance at the time of the crash. UM coverage also applies when you can’t identify a hit-and-run driver, since there’s no policy to make a claim against.

Underinsured Drivers

An underinsured driver has insurance, just not enough. Illinois only requires drivers to carry $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for injuries, and a surgery or hospital stay can use that up quickly. For insurance purposes, though, a driver counts as underinsured only when their liability limits are lower than your own UIM limits. That detail determines whether your UIM coverage pays anything.

When the At-Fault Driver Has No Insurance

If the driver who hit you had no insurance, you’ll generally file a claim with your own insurance company under your UM coverage. Because Illinois requires this coverage on auto policies, most drivers have it whether or not they remember choosing it.

A UM claim isn’t automatic, though. You still have to show that the other driver caused the crash, just as you would if they were insured. Illinois fault rules apply as well. If you’re found partly responsible, your payment is reduced by your share of the fault. If you’re more than 50% at fault, you can’t recover anything.

If the other driver fled the scene, call the police and report the crash right away. A prompt report creates a record that another driver was involved and left. That record can support a UM claim when there’s no one else to pursue.

Damage to your car is handled differently. UM bodily injury coverage pays for injuries, not vehicle repairs. Those costs typically fall under collision coverage or uninsured motorist property damage coverage, if you carry either, and you can pursue them alongside your injury claim.

What if You Were a Passenger, Pedestrian, or Cyclist?

UM coverage isn’t limited to the person behind the wheel. If you were a passenger, the UM coverage on the car you were riding in typically applies first. If that isn’t enough, or the car wasn’t insured, your own auto policy, or one belonging to a relative you live with, may provide additional coverage.

The same is true if you were walking or riding a bike. In 2023, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled that insurers can’t limit UM coverage to people inside a covered vehicle. A pedestrian or cyclist hit by an uninsured or hit-and-run driver can often turn to their own household’s auto policy, even though no car of theirs was involved.

Attorney statue

ILLINOIS CAR ACCIDENT LAWYER

CALL US NOW 847-869-9100

Other Possible Sources of Payment

UM and UIM coverage are often the main source of compensation, but they aren’t always the only one. Depending on how the crash happened, other options may include:

  • The vehicle owner’s insurance. If the at-fault driver borrowed someone else’s car with permission, the owner’s policy usually provides coverage, even if the driver has no insurance of their own.
  • The driver’s employer. If the driver was working at the time of the crash, the employer or its insurance may be responsible.
  • A bar or restaurant that served the driver. Under Illinois’s Dram Shop Act, injured people can bring claims against businesses that served alcohol to a driver who later caused a crash while intoxicated, although claims are limited.
  • Your health insurance. Health coverage can pay for treatment while the claim is pending, though your health plan may seek reimbursement from any settlement.
  • The driver personally. You can sue an uninsured driver directly, but collecting from someone without insurance or significant assets is often difficult.

Several of these sources can apply to the same crash. Some only come to light after a closer look at whose car the driver was using or where they were coming from. Identifying them early gives you a clearer picture of how much coverage is available before you make decisions about your claim.

Can You Combine Coverage From More Than One Policy?

If you insure several vehicles, you may wonder whether you can add their UM or UIM limits together. This is called “stacking,” and in Illinois the answer is usually no. State law allows insurers to include anti-stacking language in their policies, and courts enforce it when it’s clearly written, even if you pay a separate premium for each car.

There are exceptions. When a policy’s wording is unclear, Illinois courts have sometimes allowed stacking, so the exact language in your policy and on its declarations page is worth a close look.

Your Own Insurer Isn’t Automatically on Your Side

It’s natural to assume your own insurance company will be on your side. With a UM or UIM claim, though, your insurer steps into the at-fault driver’s shoes. Every dollar it pays comes out of its own pocket, so it has the same reasons any insurer would to question how the crash happened and what your injuries are worth.

Your policy also sets its own rules for these claims. Many require prompt written notice of an uninsured or underinsured motorist claim, and those requirements often run on a much shorter clock than the two-year deadline people hear about for injury lawsuits. Missing them can give the insurer grounds to deny coverage.

If you and your insurer can’t agree, the dispute usually goes to arbitration rather than a courtroom. Illinois law requires UM disputes to be arbitrated, and UIM claims are typically handled the same way. A lawyer who has handled these claims can help you meet your policy’s requirements and present your case effectively at arbitration.

What to Do After a Crash With an Uninsured or Underinsured Driver

After your crash, get the other driver’s name, license number, plate number, and insurance information if they have any. If they say they don’t have insurance, write that down and take a photo of their plate and vehicle. Call the police so the crash and the other driver’s information are documented in an official report.

See a doctor promptly, even if you feel all right. Medical records created soon after the crash help connect your injuries to it.

Then request a complete copy of your auto policy, including the declarations page. It shows your UM and UIM limits and the rules your claim will need to follow.

Talk With Robert J. Rooth About Your Uninsured Motorist Claim

Finding out the other driver had no insurance, or far too little, can make an already hard situation feel worse. There are often still options. The challenge is knowing which coverage applies, what your policy requires and how to respond when your insurance company pushes back.

Robert J. Rooth has represented injured people in Evanston and throughout Cook County since 1984. As an Evanston car accident lawyer, he can help you pursue the full value of your injury claim, and you’ll work directly with Robert. He’ll explain your options in plain terms so you can make informed decisions about your case.

Call The Rooth Law Firm to schedule a free consultation.

You’re hurt. I’m here.

Robert Rooth
The Rooth Law Firm Logo

Call An Illinois Car Accident Lawyer Today

We have been advocating for the injured since 1984. Let us fight to hold wrongdoers accountable and recover the financial damages your family needs.

CALL US NOW
Robert Rooth
Written by

Robert Rooth

Robert J. Rooth is the founder of The Rooth Law Firm, which focuses on nursing home abuse and personal injury cases. He has devoted his career to seeking justice on behalf of the underserved.